Home Secretary Yvette Cooper has called for greater transparency from police forces, including the release of information about a suspect’s ethnicity in criminal investigations. Her remarks come amid rising public pressure following recent high-profile cases involving asylum seekers, which have prompted accusations of official cover-ups.
Cooper: Government reviewing existing guidance
Speaking to BBC, Ms Cooper stated that the government was reviewing existing guidance around the disclosure of suspect information, aiming to provide the public with more transparency. She emphasized that the decision to release such details ultimately lies with police forces and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS).
“We do want to see more transparency in cases, and we think local people do need to have more information.”
Although the debate has intensified following the recent arrest and charging of two men reported to be Afghan asylum seekers in connection with the alleged rape of a 12-year-old girl in Nuneaton. The case has triggered widespread public outcry and political commentary, particularly from Reform UK’s Nigel Farage, who accused authorities of hiding the suspects’ immigration status.
In a letter to Ms Cooper, George Finch, Reform UK’s Warwickshire council leader, claimed that suppressing such information risks public disorder breaking out on the streets of Warwickshire.
To address growing concerns, Ms Cooper revealed that the Government has asked the Law Commission to accelerate its review into what information can be lawfully released by police when suspects are arrested or charged.
She referenced prior cases in which authorities disclosed such details, “When we had the very high-profile arrests and cases around national security and terrorism, the police released the fact that the suspect was Iranian. The CPS also outlined their immigration or asylum status at the point of charging.”
Ms Cooper stressed that while operational discretion remains with the police and CPS, the current rules may need to evolve to meet the demands of today’s fast-moving information environment.
The College of Policing echoed calls for clarity, noting that transparency helps prevent misinformation and builds public trust. A spokesperson confirmed that media guidance for police is currently under review, with a focus on balancing legal obligations such as contempt of court with the need to inform communities accurately.
“Police forces make challenging and complex decisions on a case-by-case basis,” the statement read. “Transparency is essential to prevent misinformation and reassure the public.”
Merseyside Police, which was at the center of past controversy over the Southport attack,, is frequently cited in the transparency debate. In that case, false rumors spread online claiming the attacker, Axel Rudakubana, was a Muslim asylum seeker. The disinformation campaign helped fuel riots.
By contrast, Merseyside Police was more forthcoming during another incident, when a white British man drove a car into crowds at a Liverpool FC victory parade. The force promptly identified the suspect’s ethnicity and nationality, which was praised as a model of responsible transparency.
Emily Spurrell, Merseyside’s Police and Crime Commissioner, acknowledged the complexity of disclosure decisions. In Rudakubana’s case, she explained, the suspect was under 18 when arrested, severely limiting what police could legally reveal.
“I think the police will always aim to be as transparent as possible,” she said on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme. “But they are limited because of their need to protect the criminal justice process.”
She also noted that much of the current media guidance was created before the rise of social media, adding, “We live in a very different world now and rumors can spread instantly, and there are bad actors who deliberately circulate false information to serve a particular agenda.”
According to Warwickshire Police, Ahmad Mulakhil, 23, was arrested on July 26 and charged the next day with rape. He appeared at Coventry Magistrates’ Court last Monday and was remanded in custody.
Another man, Mohammad Kabir, also 23, was arrested in Nuneaton days later and charged with kidnap, strangulation, and aiding and abetting the rape of a girl under 13. He appeared before the same court on Saturday and was likewise remanded.
The force has not confirmed, but also has not denied, a Mail on Sunday report that both men are asylum seekers. That silence has only added fuel to claims of a potential cover-up. However, Home Secretary’s stance signals a shift toward greater openness in criminal investigations, but challenges remain particularly around minors, live investigations, and safeguarding the integrity of the justice system.
Read also: Home Office launches crackdown on asylum seekers working illegally
