With Erik ten Hag’s dismissal following Manchester United’s challenging start to the season, the search for a new manager has begun in earnest. Several high-profile names have already emerged as potential candidates, each offering different strengths, experience, and tactical approaches that could shape United’s future. Here’s a breakdown of some of the top contenders for the role at Old Trafford.
Ruud van Nistelrooy
Managerial Record: Played 33, Won 22, Drawn 6, Lost 5 (Win percentage: 66.7%)
Former United legend and assistant to Ten Hag, Van Nistelrooy has now been given interim control of the team. Known for his prolific five-season tenure as a striker, he’s somewhat untested in long-term roles but brings a valuable connection to the club and an attacking philosophy. After his time at PSV Eindhoven, where he won the Dutch Cup, questions linger over whether he can navigate United’s complexities in a permanent position.
Graham Potter
Managerial Record: Played 397, Won 160, Drawn 119, Lost 118 (Win percentage: 40.3%)
Potter’s reputation soared at Brighton before an ill-fated tenure at Chelsea. Praised for his tactical nous and ability to build competitive teams, Potter’s name remains in circulation for major vacancies, including United’s. Known for his progressive style and rapport with players, Potter would bring both stability and ambition, though doubts persist after Chelsea’s struggles under his leadership.
Thomas Frank
Managerial Record: Played 334, Won 141, Drawn 87, Lost 107 (Win percentage: 42.2%)
Frank has done impressive work with Brentford, establishing them as a competitive force in the Premier League. His ability to maximize resources and motivate teams makes him an appealing choice. However, luring him away from Brentford could prove costly for United, and some wonder if Frank’s experience is enough for the demands of managing a club of United’s stature.
Simone Inzaghi
Managerial Record: Played 320, Won 192, Drawn 57, Lost 73 (Win percentage: 60.0%)
The Italian tactician has built a solid reputation at Inter Milan, where he won the Serie A title and reached the 2023 Champions League final. Known for his structured approach and success in high-stakes competitions, Inzaghi’s disciplined style could bring stability to United. Although he recently signed a contract extension, United might see him as the steady hand they need.
Kieran McKenna
Managerial Record: Played 124, Won 67, Drawn 39, Lost 19 (Win percentage: 54.0%)
Once part of United’s coaching staff, McKenna’s meteoric rise with Ipswich Town has turned heads. His attack-minded philosophy and success in English football make him a strong candidate for a return. Although he would be costly to release from Ipswich, his intimate knowledge of United’s system and talent for developing players could make him a worthwhile investment.
Ruben Amorim
Managerial Record: Played 244, Won 174, Drawn 34, Lost 36 (Win percentage: 71.3%)
Amorim’s success at Sporting Lisbon, where he ended a 19-year title drought, has made him one of Europe’s hottest coaching prospects. His bold, youthful approach is mirrored by his impressive win rate. A significant buyout clause with Sporting may deter United, but his ambition and adaptability could match the club’s vision for long-term growth.
Edin Terzic
Managerial Record: Played 128, Won 75, Drawn 24, Lost 29 (Win percentage: 58.5%)
Terzic led Borussia Dortmund to last season’s Champions League final before parting ways with the club. Known for his aggressive tactics and success in European competitions, Terzic’s skill in high-pressure environments could serve United well. However, his desire for a break from management might keep him out of the running.
Xavi
Managerial Record: Played 102, Won 71, Drawn 16, Lost 15 (Win percentage: 69.6%)
The former Barcelona manager, noted for his technical style and impressive track record, is a tantalizing option for United. Although currently on a break, Xavi’s interest in the Premier League could sway him if approached. However, he has publicly stated he prefers a summer return, which may not align with United’s immediate needs.
Zinedine Zidane
Managerial Record: Played 183, Won 124, Drawn 38, Lost 21 (Win percentage: 67.8%)
Zidane, who led Real Madrid to three Champions League titles, has been approached by United in the past. While a proven winner, his limited experience outside Madrid and the language barrier might deter United from making an offer. Nevertheless, the allure of Zidane’s trophy-laden record makes him a compelling option.
Roberto de Zerbi
Currently at Marseille, De Zerbi is celebrated for his attractive playing style, which made Brighton an exciting team to watch. His lack of defensive solidity may be a concern, but his offensive creativity aligns with United’s identity. The Italian’s progressive outlook could bring freshness to United’s approach.
The race to replace Ten Hag will likely come down to balancing experience with vision and fit. While Van Nistelrooy may bring continuity as interim manager, the allure of managers like Potter, Inzaghi, or Amorim could shape a bright new chapter for United.
