In a dramatic twist ahead of Manchester United’s Europa League clash with Lyon, ex-Red Devils midfielder Nemanja Matic launched a scathing verbal attack on United goalkeeper André Onana — a move that some now believe may have influenced the Cameroonian’s error-strewn performance.
Matic, now at Lyon, didn’t mince words in Wednesday’s pre-match press conference, branding Onana “one of the worst goalkeepers in Manchester United’s history” following the keeper’s confident claims that United were “way better” than their French opponents.
Fast forward 24 hours and Onana was at fault for both Lyon goals in a 2-2 draw, sparking speculation that the veteran midfielder’s comments may have gotten into his head.
Since joining United in 2023, Onana has now made eight errors leading to goals — more than any other Premier League goalkeeper in that time. Despite manager Ruben Amorim’s attempt to deflect blame, insisting he’s made more mistakes than his players, scrutiny on Onana has intensified.
Psychologists say such comments, especially coming from a former teammate, can weigh heavily on a player’s mind. “Even if you try to ignore it, those words stick,” said sports psychologist Dr. Simon Moore. “It creates added pressure to prove people wrong, which can lead to more mistakes.”
Matic, for his part, likely feels vindicated. Former England winger Aaron Lennon suggested, “Matic will sleep well tonight,” while Lyon’s Izzy Christiansen noted that Onana “looked a bit silly.”
Onana responded on social media, insisting his comments weren’t disrespectful and pointing out he’s won trophies with United — something not all critics can claim.
Experts argue that while mind games can affect performance, top-level athletes are usually equipped to bounce back. “What matters now is how Onana responds,” said sports psychologist Matt Shaw. “Rebuilding confidence is about focusing on strengths, not dwelling on criticism.”
As United prepare to face Lyon again in the return leg, the spotlight will remain fixed on Onana. Whether he can rise above the noise and regain his form may prove crucial to United’s European ambitions — and to silencing the critics.
